Category Archives: West Bengal

Politics, West Bengal

CM Mamata Banerjee Challenges Allegations Over Compensation in RG Kar Hospital Case: “No Money Was Mentioned”

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, September 9, 2024, Kolkata: 

The tragic case of the alleged rape and murder of a young doctor at RG Kar Medical College and Hospital has sparked widespread outrage and political uproar in West Bengal. The controversy has been further fueled by the state government’s mention of a ₹10 lakh compensation, which has now become a heated point of debate. Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee, for the first time, publicly addressed the issue, challenging the claims surrounding the compensation announcement.

At a recent event in Behala on August 14, Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee referred to the possibility of providing compensation in the RG Kar case. She reportedly mentioned that ₹10 lakh could be considered as compensation for the victim’s family. This statement quickly became a flashpoint for opposition leaders, who criticized the Chief Minister for what they perceived as a lack of sensitivity. Some opposition figures even sarcastically commented that the Chief Minister was “setting a price” for the life of the young doctor.

Faced with mounting criticism, Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee took a firm stance on Monday at Nabanna, the state administrative headquarters, refuting the claims about a specific compensation amount. She demanded proof from those accusing her of mentioning ₹10 lakh as compensation. “No money was mentioned,” Banerjee asserted. “Where is the proof that money was mentioned? That evidence must be provided.”

The Chief Minister’s remarks have brought a new dimension to the already volatile situation. Banerjee argued that her intention was not to offer monetary compensation but to encourage good deeds in memory of the deceased. “The family was not told about any money. If you want to do good work in the memory of the daughter, tell them. I said this,” she stated. She further emphasized that allegations about compensation being offered were baseless unless concrete evidence was presented to support them.

The controversy intensified as the victim’s family expressed their outrage over the Chief Minister’s earlier statements. Tilottama’s father, visibly angered, announced that the family would not accept any form of compensation from the government. “We do not want any government compensation from the Chief Minister,” he declared, reflecting the family’s deep disappointment and anger at how the situation has been handled at the highest level of the state administration.

Opposition parties have been relentless in their criticism, accusing the Chief Minister of undermining the gravity of the situation. They have continued to press the narrative that the state government, by allegedly mentioning compensation, was attempting to sidestep accountability for the serious lapses in law and order that may have led to the young doctor’s tragic death.

The RG Kar Hospital case has already triggered a storm of protests and political battles in West Bengal, drawing attention to issues of safety and justice in public institutions. The Chief Minister’s latest comments have only added to the controversy, highlighting the tension between the government and the opposition, as well as the emotional responses from the public and the victim’s family.

As the debate rages on, the demand for justice for the young doctor remains at the forefront, with both political and civil society groups calling for a transparent and thorough investigation. The case continues to serve as a reminder of the deep societal and administrative challenges faced by the state, as leaders navigate the complexities of governance, public sentiment, and political strategy.

The next steps in this high-profile case are likely to determine the direction of the discourse in West Bengal, as calls for accountability and justice grow louder with each passing day.
West Bengal

Chandannagar Police Commissioner Wins National Recognition for Innovative E-Governance Initiative

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, September 9, 2024, Hooghly:  

In a remarkable achievement, the Chandannagar Police Commissionerate, led by Commissioner Amit Javalgi, has been awarded the prestigious title of the “Best in the Country” by the Central Government for its groundbreaking efforts in the field of e-governance. The award recognizes the Commissioner’s innovative approach to modernizing police investigations and handling case materials through the use of advanced technology.

One of the major challenges faced by police stations across India is the effective management and preservation of seized materials that need to be presented as evidence in court proceedings. Whether it is vehicles, documents, or other confiscated items, these materials often pile up in police station premises or court warehouses, creating logistical nightmares. Some cases remain unresolved for years, making it increasingly difficult to maintain the integrity and identification of these items over prolonged periods.

The Chandannagar Police Commissionerate, under the leadership of Commissioner Amit Javalgi, has tackled this age-old problem by implementing an innovative solution that digitizes and organizes the handling of seized materials, commonly referred to as “malkhana” items. The initiative involves the full digitization of malkhanas across all police stations in the Chandannagar jurisdiction, utilizing barcoding technology to tag and track every seized item. This system ensures that each item is easily identifiable and retrievable, significantly reducing the complexities involved in managing evidence for ongoing legal cases.

Prior to this initiative, managing seized items was a cumbersome and time-consuming process. Police stations often faced space constraints as impounded vehicles and other materials accumulated in their premises. Identifying specific items among thousands of confiscated goods, some of which may have been seized a decade ago, was a daunting task. The introduction of the barcode-based digital system has revolutionized this aspect of law enforcement, ensuring greater efficiency, accuracy, and accountability.

The Central Government recognized the significance of this initiative in transforming the investigation and prosecution processes and awarded the Chandannagar Police Commissionerate a gold medal in the field of e-governance. This award is a testament to the forward-thinking approach adopted by Commissioner Amit Javalgi and his team, setting a new benchmark for police forces across the country.

Speaking on the achievement, Commissioner Amit Javalgi expressed his gratitude for the recognition and highlighted the importance of leveraging technology to address longstanding challenges in law enforcement. He stated, “Our goal was to find a sustainable and efficient solution to a problem that has plagued police stations nationwide for years. The digitization of malkhanas not only improves our ability to manage evidence but also enhances the overall integrity and transparency of the judicial process.”

The initiative has garnered widespread appreciation not only from the government but also from law enforcement agencies across India, who are looking to replicate the Chandannagar model in their jurisdictions. This recognition comes as a major boost to the efforts of the Chandannagar Police Commissionerate in setting high standards in public service delivery and governance.

The award highlights the importance of e-governance in modernizing public administration and reaffirms the need for innovative solutions in enhancing the efficiency of law enforcement agencies. With this achievement, the Chandannagar Police Commissionerate has set an example for other police forces, demonstrating how technology can be harnessed to solve real-world problems and improve public trust in the justice system.

The success of this initiative marks a significant step forward in India’s journey towards a more transparent, efficient, and accountable policing system. As other police departments take inspiration from this model, the future of law enforcement in India looks set for a transformative change, driven by innovation and a commitment to better governance.
National, Politics, West Bengal

Abhishek Banerjee Faces Setback as Supreme Court Rejects Plea in Teacher Recruitment Corruption Case

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, , KalimNews, September 9, 2024, Kolkata: In a significant development in the West Bengal teacher recruitment corruption case, Abhishek Banerjee, the All India General Secretary of the Trinamool Congress (TMC), has faced a major setback in the Supreme Court. Banerjee, whose name was implicated in the scandal, challenged the summons issued by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) for his questioning. However, the Supreme Court dismissed both his petition and that of his wife, Rujira Banerjee, leaving them with no immediate legal recourse.


The case revolves around allegations of corruption in the recruitment of teachers in West Bengal, a scandal that has rocked the state and drawn national attention. As part of the investigation, the ED had summoned Abhishek Banerjee and his wife, Rujira, for interrogation. Previously, the couple had appeared at the ED office in Kolkata’s CGO Complex for questioning. However, this time, they were summoned to appear in Delhi, a move they both contested.

Banerjee argued that the repeated summons to Delhi amounted to harassment and questioned why the interrogation could not be conducted in Kolkata, where the ED also has an office. His legal team cited potential security concerns and undue hardship as reasons for requesting the venue change. The ED, however, countered that conducting the interrogation in Kolkata might lead to security issues and insisted on holding the questioning in Delhi.

Challenging the ED’s directive, Abhishek Banerjee moved the Supreme Court, seeking relief from having to travel to Delhi. His petition argued that the enforcement agency’s insistence on Delhi as the venue was arbitrary and motivated by political vendetta. However, the Supreme Court rejected the plea, asserting that there were no grounds to interfere with the ED’s decision to summon him and his wife to the national capital.

The Supreme Court’s decision has left Banerjee and his legal team with limited options. With the dismissal of their petitions, both Abhishek and Rujira Banerjee are now expected to comply with the ED’s summons to appear for questioning in Delhi. This outcome is a significant blow to the TMC leader, who has been vocal about what he perceives as political targeting by central agencies.

In response to the Supreme Court’s verdict, Abhishek Banerjee expressed his disappointment and reiterated his stance that the repeated summons to Delhi were part of a strategy to harass him and his family. He pointed out that the ED’s office in Kolkata is fully equipped for conducting such interrogations, questioning the necessity of summoning them to Delhi.

The teacher recruitment corruption case has already implicated several high-profile figures and caused considerable political turmoil in West Bengal. Abhishek Banerjee, a prominent leader in the Trinamool Congress and nephew of West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee, has consistently denied any wrongdoing and accused the central government of using investigative agencies to target opposition leaders.

As the case unfolds, the ED’s investigation continues, and Abhishek Banerjee’s legal and political battles appear far from over. The Supreme Court’s decision has undoubtedly intensified the controversy, raising questions about the intersection of law enforcement and political rivalry in one of India’s most politically charged states.

The coming days are expected to see further legal and political maneuvers as Banerjee and the TMC brace for the next steps in what has become a high-profile and contentious case.
Crime, West Bengal

CBI Raises Multiple Questions in RG Kar Medical College Case Investigation

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, September 9, 2024, Kolkata: 

A series of serious allegations have surfaced in the ongoing investigation by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) into the RG Kar Medical College Hospital incident. The central investigating agency has obtained crucial evidence, including CCTV footage and forensic reports, raising new questions and concerns about the handling of the case.

The Chief Justice’s special bench has instructed the CBI to submit an updated status report on the investigation by Tuesday, September 17. During today’s hearing, the CBI raised significant issues about the post-mortem process conducted in the case. It was revealed that the post-mortem was performed after a specific period to facilitate a swift cremation, a decision that has come under scrutiny.

The CBI pointed out several inconsistencies and mysteries in the post-mortem procedure. Although it was conducted in the presence of a magistrate, the CBI has questioned the timing and manner of the autopsy. Adding to the complexity, the CBI acknowledged the presence of injury marks on the body of Tilottama, the deceased, which had not been sufficiently addressed in the initial reports.

The CBI’s legal representative mentioned the existence of a challan accompanying the autopsy report. However, when the Chief Justice inquired about this document, the state’s legal counsel could not provide the necessary details. This led the Chief Justice to question how the autopsy could have been carried out without all the required documentation.

Further complicating matters, the CBI highlighted discrepancies related to the CCTV footage from the hospital. When questioned about the footage, the state lawyer informed the court that it had been provided in four parts. However, senior counsel Kapil Sibal, representing the state, mentioned a “technical glitch” but failed to elaborate on what the specific error was. The CBI remained firm in its assertion that the full and complete CCTV footage had not been handed over, which casts doubt on the transparency and thoroughness of the evidence provided by the state.

Since the CBI took over the investigation five days after the incident, several key elements of the case have reportedly changed. The central agency is now faced with piecing together the altered evidence and determining the actual sequence of events that led to the tragic outcome at RG Kar Medical College Hospital.

The ongoing investigation by the CBI has certainly raised more questions than answers, and the revelations have intensified the scrutiny on the handling of the case by the state authorities. The legal battle is expected to continue, with the next status report likely shedding more light on the contentious issues that have surfaced in this high-profile case.
Politics, West Bengal

TMC MP Jahar Sarkar Resigns from Rajya Sabha, Announces Departure from Politics

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, September 8, 2024, Calcutta : In a surprising political development, Trinamool Congress (TMC) Member of Parliament Jahar Sarkar has resigned from his position as a Rajya Sabha MP. In his resignation letter addressed to TMC supremo Mamata Banerjee, Sarkar also announced his decision to withdraw from politics altogether.

The resignation comes amid heightened political tensions and public unrest surrounding the RG Kar case. Sarkar’s decision is particularly significant as he has been a prominent figure in Delhi politics, having served in various capacities as a central bureaucrat. His departure is expected to place additional pressure on the ruling party, given his extensive experience and influence.

Sarkar’s resignation follows a period of intense scrutiny and protest related to the RG Kar incident. Earlier, TMC MP Sukhendushekhar Roy had publicly supported the protestors, aligning himself with their demands. This move has fueled speculation and debate within political circles about the ruling party’s handling of the situation.

In his resignation letter, Sarkar cited the RG Kar case as a major factor in his decision to step down. He expressed deep concerns about the government’s response to the incident and questioned its handling of the situation. His resignation underscores the growing discontent among some members of the TMC regarding the party’s current political strategy and actions.

Sarkar’s departure marks a significant shift in the political landscape and may have implications for the TMC as it navigates the ongoing controversy and public dissent.

Crime, West Bengal

Haripal Incident Sparks Protests Amidst Statewide Unrest

Leave a comment
Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, September 8, 2024, Hooghly : The ongoing protests against the rape and murder of a student from RG Kar College have cast a shadow over Haripal, where a new and troubling incident has emerged. Amid the statewide unrest, a student in Haripal has alleged a rape, but initial investigations have raised doubts about the veracity of these claims.

On Friday night around 10 PM, a minor was found unconscious with torn clothes near Mahadev Cold Storage, close to the Haripal police station. Local women who discovered the student provided assistance and alerted the authorities. The police arrived promptly, and the minor was taken to Haripal Rural Hospital for treatment.

Upon regaining consciousness, the student reported being abducted by four individuals in a white car while returning from tuition at Singur. The student claimed the assailants threatened her with harm to her mother if she reported the incident. She also described being dropped off at Haripal station and coerced into walking through the local market.

However, the police have noted several inconsistencies in the student’s statement and found no evidence of rape in the physical examination. This has led to significant public skepticism and unrest.

In response to the incident, members of the Democratic Youth Federation of India (DYFI) and the Student Federation of India (SFI) gathered in front of the Haripal police station, demanding a thorough investigation and justice for the victim.

The situation remains tense as the community grapples with the impact of recent events and seeks clarity on the latest allegations.
Crime, West Bengal

ED Traces Additional Properties of Sandeep Ghosh in Kolkata

Leave a comment


Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, September 7, 2024, Kolkata: The Enforcement Directorate (ED) has traced additional properties belonging to Sandeep Ghosh, the former principal of RG Kar Medical College and Hospital, uncovering a house named ‘Ghosh Villa’ in Beleghata, along with several flats in New Town, Kolkata.

The ED has discovered two more flats near Beleghata ID Hospital, close to the four-storey house where Sandeep Ghosh resided in Beleghata. These flats reportedly include a garage with a luxury car. The caretakers of these two flats confirmed they belong to Sandeep Ghosh, although there was little activity in these properties, and they have remained closed for an extended period.

Moreover, a new luxury three-storey house named ‘Ghosh Villa’ has been uncovered in the Noapara Mallik Bagan Hatiara area of Kolkata’s New Town. This house is where Sandeep Ghosh’s parents lived. The caretaker of the Beleghata flat told reporters that Sandeep Ghosh bought the car a few months ago and would occasionally use it, parking it in the garage.

Curiously, while the nameplates of luxury flats in Canning bear clear identification, the nameplates for the two flats in Beleghata do not display any names. This has led to speculation that Sandeep Ghosh may have deliberately omitted his name to conceal his ownership.

On Friday, ED officials searched the residences of several of Ghosh’s relatives, including his house in Beleghata. Following an extensive search, the ED arrested a person named Prasun Chattopadhyay. The ED is investigating where the money from the financial irregularities at RG Kar Medical College went and whether this extensive property was purchased in line with Sandeep Ghosh’s legitimate income.

In another development, the State Medical Council has issued a notice to Dr. Sandeep Ghosh, condemning his actions as the former principal of RG Kar Medical College and Hospital. As a result, Ghosh’s troubles have deepened. Last Friday, the Medical Council informed him that if a satisfactory response is not provided within three days, his medical registration will be canceled. However, it should be noted that the health department had already suspended Sandeep Ghosh earlier.

Politics, West Bengal

Governor Likely to Withhold Clearance for ‘Aparajita’ Bill, Citing Lack of Technical Report from State Government

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, Kolkata, September 6, 2024: West Bengal Governor C.V. Ananda Bose has indicated that Raj Bhavan may not give its assent to the ‘Aparajita’ Bill, recently passed by the state assembly, due to procedural lapses by the state government. The Governor has pointed out that the bill, aimed at protecting the rights of unprivileged women and children, was submitted without the requisite technical report, a critical document needed for his approval.

In a statement issued from Raj Bhavan, Governor Bose made it clear that without the necessary technical documentation, the bill cannot be cleared. “No technical report has been sent by the state with this bill, which is necessary for giving clearance to the bill. Despite knowing that, the state has not sent any technical report,” stated the Governor. The Governor further criticized the state government, alleging that this is not the first time such a procedural lapse has occurred, and he suggested that the state is well aware of these requirements but has chosen to ignore them.

The Governor also noted that the ‘Aparajita’ Bill is not unique, but rather an imitation of similar women’s protection bills currently pending with the President of India, including those from Andhra Pradesh, Arunachal Pradesh, and Maharashtra. “The Aparajita Bill of Bengal is nothing new. It is just an imitation of Andhra, Arunachal, Maharashtra Women’s Protection Bills. These bills are now lying with the President. The Chief Minister deliberately brought such bills despite knowing it,” said Governor Bose.

The statement from Raj Bhavan has highlighted a growing tension between the Governor’s office and the state administration. “It is the duty of the state government to send its technical report along with the bill. The state government has not sent it. This is not the first time that the state government has blamed the Raj Bhavan for withholding the bill despite not sending the technical report several times,” the statement read.

The Governor reportedly communicated his concerns directly to Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee, advising the state to conduct thorough homework before introducing bills in the assembly. This move has sparked a fresh political confrontation between the Raj Bhavan and the ruling Trinamool Congress government.

As per legislative procedures in India, after a bill is passed by a state assembly, it is sent to the Governor for approval. If the Governor signs the bill, it becomes law. However, if the Governor withholds assent or does not take a decision on the bill for a prolonged period, the bill may be sent to the President of India for final approval. In this case, the Governor’s reservations could potentially lead to such an escalation, delaying the implementation of the bill.

The ‘Aparajita’ Bill, officially titled the “Unprivileged Women and Children Bill,” was unanimously passed by the West Bengal State Assembly last Tuesday. Following its passage, the Leader of the Opposition, Subhendu Adhikari, expressed his support, stating, “As a responsible opposition, we will help pass the bill.” However, with the Governor’s reservations coming to light, the political dynamics have taken a sharp turn.

Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee has responded by urging opposition leaders to put pressure on the Governor to clear the bill. “Opposition leaders should ask the Governor to approve the bill soon,” said Banerjee, emphasizing the urgency of the matter.

Meanwhile, the Trinamool Mahila Morcha, the women’s wing of the ruling party, has threatened to stage a dharna (sit-in protest) in front of the Raj Bhavan if the bill does not receive clearance. The announcement from the Mahila Morcha signals the potential for heightened political drama in the coming days, as tensions between the Raj Bhavan and the state government continue to rise.

The fate of the ‘Aparajita’ Bill now hangs in the balance. If the Governor withholds his assent or sends the bill back for reconsideration, the state government may need to address the technical deficiencies pointed out by the Governor. Alternatively, if the bill is sent to the President of India, it could face further delays, given that similar bills from other states are already pending at that level.

As both the state government and Raj Bhavan brace for the next steps, the standoff over the ‘Aparajita’ Bill is becoming a key test of governance and political maneuvering in West Bengal. The outcome will not only affect the bill’s future but could also have broader implications for state-center relations and the functioning of democratic institutions in the state.

Crime, West Bengal

ED Arrests Prasun Chatterjee, Close Associate of RG Kar Hospital’s Former Principal Sandeep Ghosh, from Subhashgram

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, Kolkata, September 6, 2024: In a significant development in the RG Kar Medical College and Hospital corruption case, the Enforcement Directorate (ED) arrested Prasun Chatterjee, a close associate and self-proclaimed Personal Assistant (PA) of the disgraced former principal Dr. Sandeep Ghosh. The arrest took place in Subhashgram, located in South 24 Parganas district, following a day-long search of multiple properties linked to the corruption scandal.


Early on Friday morning, ED officials, accompanied by central armed forces, descended on Subhashgram and began searching the residence of Prasun Chatterjee. Chatterjee, who worked as a data entry operator at the National Medical College Hospital, has been closely associated with Dr. Sandeep Ghosh and is suspected of playing a key role in facilitating financial irregularities at RG Kar Hospital.

The search operation, which lasted for several hours, resulted in the discovery of incriminating documents and evidence that allegedly tied Chatterjee to the corruption scheme. Following the search, the ED arrested Prasun Chatterjee. Before being taken away by central forces, Chatterjee, when questioned by journalists, stated, “I have told everything that needed to be known,” but refrained from commenting on the extent of Dr. Sandeep Ghosh’s involvement in the financial corruption at RG Kar Hospital.

As Chatterjee was escorted into the ED vehicle, a crowd of neighbors and locals gathered, shouting slogans demanding justice. The “We Want Justice” chants underscored the public outrage surrounding the case, which has seen multiple high-profile figures entangled in allegations of widespread corruption. The arrest of Chatterjee, a relatively low-profile yet pivotal figure, has added another layer of complexity to an already high-stakes investigation.

The ED’s investigation into the RG Kar corruption case has revealed an extensive network of hidden assets and properties allegedly owned by Dr. Sandeep Ghosh. During Friday’s operation, the ED conducted simultaneous searches at at least nine locations, including Ghosh’s personal residence, his in-laws’ house, his sister-in-law’s residence, and properties belonging to his associates in Howrah, such as businessmen Kaushik Kole and Biplab Singhar.

Among the properties unearthed by the ED were a massive resort in Sonarpur and a luxurious garden house in Canning, both of which are believed to be owned by Dr. Ghosh. These properties, reportedly worth crores, are now under the ED’s scrutiny as they attempt to trace the flow of money and uncover the full extent of the financial misconduct.

Prasun Chatterjee’s role in the RG Kar corruption scandal appears to have been multifaceted. According to ED sources, Chatterjee was deeply involved in managing financial transactions and might have acted as a conduit for siphoning off funds. His position as a self-proclaimed PA to Dr. Ghosh gave him access to sensitive information and operational control, which investigators believe he exploited to further the corruption scheme.

The arrest has also raised questions about Chatterjee’s presence at RG Kar Hospital’s seminar hall on a critical day related to the corruption investigation. While details remain unclear, it is suspected that Chatterjee may have been involved in attempts to manipulate or cover up evidence. Sources also reveal that Chatterjee allegedly played a role in attempting to bribe the victim’s family to suppress information related to the case, a claim that has further complicated the investigation.
Adding to the ongoing investigation, CBI officials visited the home of the victim’s parents on Friday to discuss these developments. The parents had previously alleged that DC Central had offered them money to cover up the case, a claim that has raised eyebrows and added another dimension to the already controversial investigation. The CBI is now closely examining these allegations and gathering further evidence to corroborate the claims.

The arrest of Prasun Chatterjee marks a significant turning point in the RG Kar corruption case as the ED continues to unravel a complex web of deceit, corruption, and potential money laundering. With Chatterjee now in custody, the ED is expected to intensify its probe into Dr. Sandeep Ghosh’s financial dealings and connections. The investigation could potentially lead to more arrests and uncover additional hidden assets linked to the scandal.

As the case unfolds, both the ED and CBI are under immense pressure to bring the perpetrators to justice and restore public confidence in the state’s healthcare administration. The investigation into the RG Kar Medical College corruption case continues to be one of the most closely watched legal dramas in recent times, with the public eagerly awaiting further revelations and accountability from those involved.
Crime, West Bengal

ED Raids House of RG Kar Principal Sandeep Ghosh’s Father-in-Law Amid Ongoing Corruption Investigation

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, September 6, 2024, Hooghly: The usually quiet neighborhood of Padripara in Ward No. 16 under the Hooghly Chandannagar Municipal Corporation was shaken on Friday morning when a team from the Enforcement Directorate (ED), accompanied by central forces, arrived to conduct a raid. The target of their search was the residence of the father-in-law of Dr. Sandeep Ghosh, the former principal of RG Kar Medical College and Hospital, who was recently arrested by the CBI in connection with a high-profile corruption case.


The unexpected arrival of the ED and central forces caused a wave of speculation and curiosity among the local residents, who were left wondering about the nature of the raid. The news quickly spread throughout the neighborhood, drawing a crowd of onlookers trying to grasp the situation.

The ED team, upon reaching the residence, was reportedly met with a surprising discovery. The house of Dr. Ghosh’s father-in-law had been locked and unoccupied for a long time, leaving the ED officials without access to the property. Neighbors informed the ED team that the house had been closed for five to six years, with no recent activity or visitors. As a result, the officials left the location without carrying out any further investigation at the site.

Speaking to the media, a local resident said, “This house has been shut for years. We haven’t seen anyone coming or going for a long time. Because the house was closed, the ED couldn’t find anything or conduct their search properly.” The ED team, seemingly unprepared for the unoccupied state of the house, concluded their raid and departed, leaving behind more questions than answers.

The raid comes in the wake of the ongoing investigation into the financial corruption scandal at RG Kar Medical College and Hospital, where Dr. Sandeep Ghosh is alleged to have been involved in large-scale financial misconduct during his tenure as principal. The Calcutta High Court had previously ordered a CBI investigation into the corruption allegations, leading to Dr. Ghosh’s arrest. Following this, the ED also launched its probe, focusing on potential money laundering angles related to the case.

The raid at Dr. Ghosh’s father-in-law’s house suggests that the ED is expanding its investigation to explore any possible links or transactions that could be connected to the corruption case. The ED typically conducts such raids to uncover evidence of illicit financial activities, including hidden assets, unexplained wealth, or records of transactions that could substantiate allegations of corruption and money laundering.

While the raid did not yield immediate results due to the house being vacant, it underscores the seriousness with which the central agencies are pursuing the RG Kar corruption case. The involvement of both the CBI and ED highlights the complexity of the investigation, with authorities likely probing multiple leads to build a comprehensive case.

The ED’s action also indicates that family members and associates of those directly accused, such as Dr. Ghosh, could also be under scrutiny as investigators look into all possible avenues of financial misconduct. The fact that the ED went ahead with the raid despite the house being uninhabited for years may suggest that they are following a specific lead or tip-off that connects the property to the ongoing investigation.

The raid has sparked a range of reactions from the local residents and those following the case closely. While the immediate outcome of the raid was inconclusive, the mere presence of ED and central forces in a residential area is enough to generate a buzz and heighten the sense of anticipation surrounding the case.

Meanwhile, officials from the ED have remained tight-lipped about the specifics of the raid and the broader scope of their investigation. However, sources indicate that more such actions could be on the horizon as the agency continues to follow the money trail and uncover the depth of the corruption scandal at RG Kar Medical College.

As the investigations by both the CBI and ED progress, it is expected that further raids and actions will be carried out to bring to light the full extent of the financial irregularities and to hold those responsible accountable. The unfolding situation continues to be a closely watched development, both for its legal implications and for the impact it may have on the state’s medical and administrative landscape.
Politics, West Bengal

Governor Hints at Withholding Clearance for Aparajita Bill Amid Political Tensions

Leave a comment
Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, Kolkata, September 6, 2024: In a significant political development, West Bengal Governor C.V. Ananda Bose has hinted that the Raj Bhavan will likely withhold clearance for the ‘Aparajita’ Bill, recently passed by the state assembly. Governor Bose cited the absence of a required technical report from the state government as the primary reason for not granting assent to the bill.
“No technical report has been sent by the state with this bill, which is necessary for giving clearance,” stated the Governor, expressing concerns over the procedural lapses by the state government. “Despite knowing that, the state has not sent any technical report,” he added, indicating a clear stance against the bill without the necessary documentation.
The ‘Aparajita’ Bill, formally named the “Unprivileged Women and Children Bill,” aims to address the protection and rights of underprivileged women and children in the state. It was passed unanimously by the West Bengal Legislative Assembly last Tuesday. The bill received support even from the opposition, with Leader of the Opposition, Subhendu Adhikari, stating that they would assist in the bill’s passage as “a responsible opposition.”
However, Governor Bose criticized the bill as an “imitation” of similar legislation from other states like Andhra Pradesh, Arunachal Pradesh, and Maharashtra. “The Aparajita Bill of Bengal is nothing new. It is just an imitation of Andhra, Arunachal, and Maharashtra Women’s Protection Bills. These bills are now lying with the President,” he remarked, suggesting that the Chief Minister deliberately pushed such a bill despite knowing its possible fate.
The Governor’s Office issued a statement emphasizing the procedural protocol that the state government must follow. “It is the duty of the state government to send its technical report along with the bill. The state government has not sent it. This is not the first time that the state government has blamed the Raj Bhavan for withholding the bill despite not sending the technical report several times,” read the statement. The Governor has also communicated with Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee, advising that “the State should do more homework before introducing the Bill.”
As per established legislative procedures, once a bill is passed by the state assembly, it is forwarded to the Governor for assent. If the Governor approves it, the bill becomes law. If the Governor is unable to decide, the bill is escalated to the President of India, who makes the final decision.
The Chief Minister has responded to the Governor’s comments, urging the opposition to put pressure on the Governor to approve the bill. “Opposition leaders should ask the governor to approve the bill soon,” she stated, emphasizing the need for swift action on this issue.
Meanwhile, the Trinamool Mahila Morcha, the women’s wing of the ruling Trinamool Congress, has warned of protests if the Governor refuses to clear the bill. “If the governor does not give clearance to the bill, they will sit on dharna in front of the Raj Bhavan,” a spokesperson for the organization declared.
The situation is poised to escalate into a broader political confrontation, with the state’s ruling party and opposition aligning on the bill, while the Governor stands firm on procedural grounds. The unfolding scenario is likely to test the dynamics between the state government and Raj Bhavan, potentially impacting future legislative processes in West Bengal. 
Crime, West Bengal

ED raids houses of ex-principal of RG Kar hospital, aides over financial irregularities

Leave a comment

MP, 6 September 2024, Kolkata: Enforcement Directorate (ED) officers on Friday conducted simultaneous search operations at the residences of Sandip Ghosh, the former principal of the state-run RG Kar Medical College and Hospital, and three of his associates in connection with alleged financial irregularities at the institute, an officer said. 

The raids were carried out at Ghosh’s residence in Beliaghata and at two locations in Howrah and Subhasgram. 
All the four are already in CBI custody. “We reached these places around 6.15 am and started our raids,” the officer said. 
The ED has filed an Enforcement Case Information Report (ECIR) against Ghosh, which is analogous to a First Information Report (FIR) in criminal cases. 
On August 23, the Calcutta High Court ordered the transfer of the investigation into the alleged financial irregularities at state-run hospital from a state-constituted Special Investigation Team (SIT) to the CBI.
This decision followed a petition by Dr. Akhtar Ali, the former deputy superintendent of the facility, who sought an investigation by the ED into multiple allegations of financial misconduct during Ghosh’s tenure as principal.
Ghosh served as principal from February 2021 to September 2023. He was briefly transferred from RG Kar in October 2023 but was reinstated within a month. Dr. Ali had raised concerns that the corruption at RG Kar hospital might be linked to the doctor’s death, suggesting that the victim was aware of the misconduct and might have threatened to expose it. 
https://www.millenniumpost.in/big-stories/ed-raids-houses-of-ex-principal-of-rg-kar-hospital-aides-over-financial-irregularities-578626
National, West Bengal

The Legacy of a Monk and a Businessman: How Vivekananda’s Counsel Helped Forge Tata Steel and Scientific Institutions

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, August 31, 2024 : In July 1893, two passengers on a ship traveling from Yokohama to Vancouver were an ocher-robed monk and a middle-aged Parsi businessman. During the 12-day journey, their conversation began. One was heading to the USA for business, while the other was on his way to the Chicago World’s Parliament of Religions. One was Swami Vivekananda, and the other was Jamshedji Tata, the father of modern Indian industry.


Their discussion turned to India’s future economy and trade. Swami Vivekananda encouraged Jamshedji to establish steel factories and educational institutions in India. During their conversation, Vivekananda raised the issue of Japan’s Deslai factory, questioning why Jamshedji was not building a factory in India instead of importing Deslai from Japan. He argued that having a factory in India would strengthen the country’s economy by providing employment and keeping wealth within the nation. Jamshedji Tata was impressed by the insights of the monk.

Swami Vivekananda elaborated on the oppression of the Indian people under British rule and the struggle of obtaining basic necessities. On September 11, 1893, Vivekananda gained global recognition with his historic speech at the Chicago World’s Parliament of Religions. Jamshedji Tata, residing in Bombay, was pleased with Vivekananda’s success and was deeply moved by their shipboard conversation.

On November 23, 1898, Jamshedji wrote to Swami Vivekananda, expressing his intention to establish an institution for scientific research and requesting a pamphlet to promote science education in India. Although Swami Vivekananda was occupied with the Ramakrishna Mission and unable to fulfill the request himself, he asked his sister, Sister Nivedita, to meet with Jamshedji Tata.

Swami Vivekananda passed away in 1902, and Jamshedji Tata died in 1904. Tata’s vision of a steel industry in India was carried forward by his successors. In 1907, Tata Steel was established and has since become one of the largest multinational companies. Additionally, the Indian Institute of Science, founded in 1909 through the efforts of the Tata family, remains a source of pride for India today.
Crime, West Bengal

CBI Questions Female Assistant Superintendent in RG Kar Hospital Case: Suspicious Behavior Under Scrutiny

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, August 31, 2024, Kolkata : The female Assistant Superintendent of RG Kar Hospital is now under intense scrutiny by the CBI in connection with the rape and murder case involving a young doctor at the hospital. The CBI has begun questioning her regarding the circumstances surrounding the doctor’s death.


The investigation follows a complaint from the doctor Tilottama’s parents, who allege that the Assistant Superintendent first contacted them regarding their daughter’s illness and later informed them of her suicide. This has led to heightened scrutiny of the Assistant Superintendent’s actions.

In a recent hearing, the Supreme Court raised questions about this official’s conduct. Justice Pardiwala queried state lawyer Kapil Sibal about the Assistant Superintendent’s identity, asking, “Who is this Assistant Superintendent? Is he a woman or a man?” When Sibal confirmed that the official is indeed a woman, Justice Pardiwala expressed concern over her suspicious behavior, questioning, “What is the reason behind her behavior?”

Adding to the controversy, three audio recordings have surfaced, showing conversations between the Assistant Superintendent and the young doctor’s father. In the first call, the Assistant Superintendent reportedly instructed the father to come to the hospital quickly due to the daughter’s illness. In a subsequent call, she informed him of the suicide and death, urging him to arrive as soon as possible.

The Assistant Superintendent, currently under CBI interrogation, claims that her statements about the suicide were made under significant stress and amidst the presence of numerous students and officials after the doctor’s body was recovered. This defense is part of her ongoing explanation to the CBI.
Crime, Politics, West Bengal

Debate Intensifies Over Arjikar Case as Questions Arise About Police Handling and FIR Timing

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, August 31, 2024, Kolkata : The investigation into the RG Kar Hospital case, involving the tragic death of a female doctor, has ignited a fresh wave of debate as new, potentially explosive information emerges. The case, which has already attracted significant judicial scrutiny, is now facing intense scrutiny over the handling of the FIR and the procedural actions of the police.


Delayed FIR Sparks Legal and Public Outcry

The Calcutta High Court and the Supreme Court have both previously expressed concerns over the delayed registration of the FIR. The incident in question unfolded on August 9, when the police arrived at RG Kar Hospital by 10 a.m. to investigate the death of the female doctor. Despite their prompt arrival, the FIR was not lodged until 11:45 p.m. on the same day—well after the body had been recovered and examined.

The FIR, filed at Tala police station under FIR No. 52, accuses an unidentified individual of intentional rape and murder. This delay in FIR registration has become a focal point of contention, with critics questioning the effectiveness and transparency of the investigative process.

FIR Content and Discrepancies

The FIR was initially recorded based on General Diary No. 577, with the formal complaint being filed around 12:15 p.m. on August 9. The FIR references Unnatural Death Case No. 861, citing Sections 64 (rape) and 103 (1) (murder) of the Indian Penal Code. However, the post-mortem report, which is crucial to establishing the cause of death and the nature of any assault, did not directly confirm rape. This discrepancy has led to widespread questioning of the police’s decision to include allegations of rape and murder in the FIR without concrete forensic evidence.

Family’s Outcry and Demands for Justice

The victim’s family has publicly expressed their frustration and dismay over the handling of the case. They have alleged that their daughter was subjected to severe torture and ultimately murdered, and are demanding exemplary punishment for those responsible. Their concern is compounded by the apparent mismatch between the FIR’s allegations and the post-mortem findings, which they argue undermines the integrity of the investigation.

Criticism from the Medical Community

An agitating doctor involved in the case has voiced strong criticism of the police’s actions, particularly the decision to file an FIR based on assumptions of criminal activity rather than on substantiated evidence. The lack of direct evidence of rape has further fueled skepticism about the thoroughness and objectivity of the investigation.

Ongoing Controversy and Investigation

As the investigation continues, the controversy surrounding the FIR timing and content remains unresolved. The case has raised critical concerns about procedural integrity and the administration of justice, highlighting the need for transparency and accountability in high-profile investigations. The legal and public discourse surrounding the Arjikar case underscores the broader issues of procedural justice and the need for rigorous investigative standards.
National, Politics, West Bengal

Union Minister Criticizes Mamata Banerjee Over RG Kar Scandal and Fast Track Court Claims

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, August 31, 2024, New Delhi : The ongoing RG Kar Hospital scandal has prompted a sharp exchange between Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee and the Union Minister for Women and Child Welfare, Annapurna Devi. The latest development involves a response from the Union Minister to a recent letter from Banerjee, highlighting discrepancies and criticisms related to the handling of rape cases and the functioning of Fast Track Courts.


In her letter to the Prime Minister, Mamata Banerjee reiterated her call for stricter laws to address rape and improve the justice system’s efficiency. This request follows a series of high-profile cases that have underscored the need for more robust legal measures.

Responding to Banerjee’s letter, Union Minister Annapurna Devi issued a second letter, addressing several points raised by the Chief Minister. Devi emphasized that the state administration’s approach to investigating rape cases must be more sensitive and proactive. She asserted that existing Indian laws, including the Indian Penal Code and the Indian Civil Protection Code, already provide comprehensive measures for addressing and investigating rape within specified timelines.

Devi also contested Banerjee’s statements regarding the Fast Track Courts. The Union Minister clarified that the Fast Track Special Courts established under the central scheme, intended specifically for handling rape and POCSO (Protection of Children from Sexual Offences) cases, are distinct from the Fast Track Courts operating in West Bengal. Devi highlighted that West Bengal still has a backlog of 48,600 rape and POCSO cases that remain unresolved.

Furthermore, Devi rejected Banerjee’s claim of a shortage of judicial officers in Fast Track Courts. According to Devi, the current judicial framework and resources are adequate for handling the cases, and the focus should be on ensuring effective implementation of existing legal provisions.

The exchange underscores the contentious debate over the handling of sexual violence cases and the effectiveness of legal mechanisms designed to address such issues. As the RG Kar scandal continues to unfold, the contrasting perspectives of state and central authorities reflect ongoing tensions and challenges in the pursuit of justice.
Crime, National, West Bengal

DNA Report Confirms Sanjay Roy as Rapist in High-Profile RG Kar Case; CBI Faces Pressure to Uncover More Complexities

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, August 31, 2024, Kolkata: In a dramatic turn of events, the highly publicized RG Kar rape and murder case has taken a significant step forward with the release of a damning DNA report by the Central Forensic Science Lab (CFSL). The report conclusively identifies Sanjay Roy, a civic volunteer, as the rapist of the female doctor, setting the stage for a potential landmark judgment.


Forensic Evidence Points Decisively at Sanjay Roy
The CFSL report, awaited for months, has confirmed that Sanjay Roy’s DNA matches the semen samples found on the body of the murdered doctor. This finding is critical, as it not only ties Roy directly to the crime but also strengthens the case against him amidst growing calls for justice from the public and the medical community. The DNA evidence was gathered from various sources, including samples collected from the victim’s body during the post-mortem, Sanjay Roy’s clothing from the night of the incident, bed sheets from the seminar room, a red blanket, and hair samples seized from the crime scene.

CBI Investigation Intensifies Amidst Public Outcry
With the forensic evidence squarely pointing to Sanjay Roy, the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) has now intensified its probe into the RG Kar case. Despite the clarity provided by the DNA report, the investigation is far from over. Public sentiment has been highly charged, with significant pressure on the CBI to delve deeper and unravel any potential hidden layers to this heinous crime.

Rumors and speculations have been circulating widely, with some doctors and members of the public suggesting the possibility of a gang rape. The outrage has been palpable, with demands for a more thorough investigation to ensure that all culprits are brought to justice. “The DNA evidence is a step forward, but it might just be the tip of the iceberg. There could be more involved,” said a senior doctor from RG Kar Medical College who wished to remain anonymous.

CBI Faces Pressure to Provide Admissible Evidence and Clarity
The CFSL’s findings provide the CBI with a solid foundation to proceed, but the road ahead is fraught with complexities. The investigative agency must now piece together the remaining evidence and testimonies to build a compelling case that can withstand scrutiny in court. In cases involving such intense public interest, the need for concrete, admissible evidence is crucial to prevent any loopholes that could lead to the accused walking free.

The CFSL report hints that there could be more angles to explore, suggesting that Sanjay Roy’s actions may be only a part of the larger narrative. The CBI’s next steps are critical, as any missteps could lead to further public distrust and backlash. Legal experts have pointed out that while DNA evidence is powerful, a comprehensive investigation is essential to corroborate it with circumstantial evidence, witness testimonies, and other forensic findings to ensure a watertight case.

A Community on Edge: Calls for Justice and Accountability
The RG Kar case has gripped the city of Kolkata and drawn national attention, becoming a flashpoint for discussions on women’s safety, the accountability of civic volunteers, and the efficacy of law enforcement. Public demonstrations have erupted across the city, with activists, medical professionals, and concerned citizens demanding swift justice and more stringent measures to protect women. The case has also raised questions about the accountability of civic volunteers like Sanjay Roy and the systems in place to prevent such crimes.

Many in the community feel that this case represents more than just one tragic incident; it symbolizes a larger systemic failure that needs urgent redressal. “We need more than just one man being held accountable. We need to ensure this never happens again,” said a protestor at a recent rally.

What Lies Ahead?
As the CBI navigates through the complexities of this case, the spotlight remains on the need for transparency and thoroughness. The public, the media, and legal observers are all watching closely as the investigation unfolds. The CFSL report has provided a pivotal breakthrough, but it has also raised more questions about what really happened that fateful night at RG Kar Medical College.

The road to justice may still be long, but the CFSL report has brought the truth closer to light. For now, the nation waits with bated breath to see how the investigation develops and whether it will bring closure to a case that has shaken Kolkata to its core.