Category Archives: Politics

Politics, West Bengal

State Government Faces Scrutiny from Calcutta High Court Over Kolkata Police Notification

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, September 27, 2024, Calcutta: The state government is once again under the spotlight as the Calcutta High Court raises questions about a notification issued by the Kolkata Police. The notification, released by Lalbazar (the Kolkata Police headquarters), places restrictions on gatherings in a large section of central Kolkata, sparking controversy and legal challenges.


The notice, which prohibits the assembly of more than five people in certain key areas of the city, has become a focal point of legal debate. The restricted zones include Boubazar, Hare Street, Traffic Guard, and the Headquarters area—all centered around the bustling Dharmatala region. According to the notification, these restrictions are set to be in place from September 25 to November 23, 2024, a period that overlaps with several major festivals, including Durga Puja.

The state government faced tough questions during a hearing on Friday, presided over by Justice Rajshree Bharadwaj of the Calcutta High Court. The central issue revolved around whether the state would reconsider or withdraw the police notification, especially given the upcoming festive season, which typically draws large crowds. Justice Bharadwaj pointedly asked, “Is there any reason to withdraw this notification, or will all pujas in the area have to be stopped?”

The timing of the notification, issued just days before the start of Durga Puja preparations, has raised several concerns, particularly among community organizers. The restriction on gatherings has been seen by some as an attempt to curb potential protests during the festive period, sparking confusion and speculation about the motive behind the move.

The state’s counsel responded to the court, noting that such restrictions, including the enforcement of Section 163, have historically been in place in areas like KC Das to Victoria House, even in past years. However, the state also acknowledged that this year’s notification has introduced an extended enforcement area, including the Bentinck Street area, which has led to some confusion.

Advocate Vikas Ranjan Bhattacharya, representing the petitioners, raised concerns about the impact of the police directive on the numerous pujas and community celebrations held within the restricted zones. The court sought clarification from the state on how these restrictions would affect the festive proceedings in police stations where major pujas are organized.

The notification has drawn criticism for potentially disrupting the city’s biggest cultural and religious events, and many argue that the timing of its enforcement is poorly planned. Several civic groups and political commentators have questioned whether the move is aimed at stifling political protests rather than addressing public safety, adding a layer of complexity to the legal proceedings.

As tensions rise over the notification, the Calcutta High Court has scheduled another hearing on the matter for next Monday, where further arguments will be presented. The outcome of this case could have significant implications not only for the state government but also for the city’s cultural landscape during one of the most important festival seasons of the year. 
National, Politics

Rahul Gandhi Takes on Major Responsibility as Member of Parliamentary Standing Committee on Defense

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, September 27, 2024, New Delhi: Congress MP and Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi, has been entrusted with a significant new responsibility as a member of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Defense. This appointment marks a return for Gandhi, who previously served on the committee. The Rajya Sabha Secretariat officially announced the formation of various parliamentary committees, revealing a reshuffling of key figures in crucial roles.


Apart from Gandhi, notable appointments were made, including Bollywood actress and BJP MP Kangana Ranaut, who has been made a member of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Information Technology. Joining her on this committee are Samajwadi Party MP Jaya Bachchan and Trinamool Congress MP Mahua Moitra, making the panel a diverse mix of political and public figures.

Rahul Gandhi’s appointment to the defense committee is seen as an acknowledgment of his growing role in national politics, particularly in matters of national security and defense. The defense committee will be headed by BJP MP Radhamohan Singh, and Gandhi’s inclusion signals his continued influence in critical policy discussions.

In addition to Gandhi, several other prominent MPs from the Congress party have been appointed to key parliamentary committees. Congress MP and former Foreign Minister Shashi Tharoor has been appointed as the chairman of the Foreign Affairs Committee, underscoring his expertise in international relations.

The Congress party has also secured responsibilities in other important committees, including those on Education, Women and Child Welfare, Youth, and Sports. Veteran Congress leader Digvijay Singh will lead the Education, Women and Child Welfare committee, reflecting the party’s strategic placement in areas of social and educational policy.

However, notably absent from any committee is seven-time MP and former Congress president Sonia Gandhi, raising questions about her reduced role in parliamentary affairs. This has sparked speculation about the future direction of leadership within the Congress party and her involvement moving forward.

Meanwhile, the Trinamool Congress (TMC) has also made significant strides in parliamentary representation. Veteran TMC MP Dola Sen has been named chairperson of the Parliamentary Standing Committee. In addition, Burdwan-Durgapur MP and former national cricketer Keerti Azad has been appointed as the chairman of the standing committee under the Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilizers, giving the former sports star an important role in shaping policy within this sector.

These appointments come at a critical time as the newly-formed standing committees are expected to play a pivotal role in addressing pressing issues related to defense, foreign affairs, education, and other key sectors in the upcoming parliamentary sessions. With Rahul Gandhi’s return to the Defense Committee and other key appointments, the Congress is positioning itself for an active and influential role in shaping policy and legislation.
National, Politics

Yogi Adityanath’s Bold Claim: “India Will Reclaim Pakistan-Occupied Kashmir if BJP Returns to Power in Jammu & Kashmir”

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, September 27, 2024, New Delhi: Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath made a powerful and controversial statement during a BJP election rally in the RS Pura area of Jammu, declaring that India will reclaim Pakistan-Occupied Kashmir (PoK) once the BJP comes to power in Jammu and Kashmir. His remarks have sparked intense political discussions and drawn national attention as the final phase of elections in the region approaches.


While addressing the crowd, Adityanath asserted, “Pakistan-Occupied Kashmir is an integral part of Jammu and Kashmir. The process of bringing PoK under Indian control will commence only when the BJP returns to power in Jammu and Kashmir.” His bold declaration was framed as a direct threat to Pakistan, with the Chief Minister emphasizing India’s readiness to assert control over the disputed territory.

He further added, “India stands strong, while Pakistan is on the brink of collapse. Today, it is clear to the world that Pakistan is bankrupt, its people are protesting in the streets, and the government is struggling to manage its affairs.” Adityanath highlighted the stark contrast between the two nations, portraying Pakistan as a failing state beset by internal strife and economic instability.

In an even more scathing attack, Adityanath labeled Pakistan as the “enemy of humanity” and referred to it as the “cancer of humanity.” He went on to claim that people worldwide are now calling for the eradication of this “cancer,” reinforcing his position that Pakistan is not only a threat to India but to global stability.

These remarks come at a critical time, with the third and final phase of elections in Jammu and Kashmir heating up. Yogi Adityanath’s fiery rhetoric is seen as a rallying cry to BJP supporters, pushing a strong nationalist agenda and positioning the BJP as the party that can secure Jammu and Kashmir’s future—including taking decisive action on Pakistan-Occupied Kashmir.

Political analysts view this statement as a high-stakes strategy aimed at consolidating nationalist sentiment and energizing BJP’s base in a region crucial to India’s security and sovereignty. However, the statement has also ignited debates among opposition parties, some of whom have accused the BJP of escalating tensions with Pakistan for electoral gains.

In recent years, the status of Pakistan-Occupied Kashmir has been a topic of great sensitivity in Indian politics, particularly since the abrogation of Article 370 in 2019, which stripped Jammu and Kashmir of its special status. Adityanath’s speech signals the BJP’s continued hardline stance on the Kashmir issue, reinforcing its commitment to territorial integrity and national security.

As the political temperature rises ahead of the elections, Adityanath’s statement has added a new dimension to the ongoing discourse about Jammu and Kashmir’s future and the geopolitical relationship between India and Pakistan.
National, Politics

Nitin Gadkari Declines Offer to Become Prime Minister, Fuels Speculation in National Politics

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, September 27, 2024, New Delhi: In a surprising revelation, veteran BJP leader and Union Minister for Road Transport and Highways, Nitin Gadkari, disclosed that he was offered the position of Prime Minister multiple times. This statement has sparked widespread speculation in national political circles, particularly about Gadkari’s relationship with Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his standing within the BJP.


In an interview, Gadkari revealed that offers for the Prime Ministership came both before and after the recent Lok Sabha elections. However, he categorically stated that these offers did not come from within the BJP. “There is no question of deviating from my ideals. I have never had the intention of becoming Prime Minister. I live by my ideology,” Gadkari clarified, reinforcing his commitment to his principles.

The confession has stirred debates about internal rifts within the BJP and whether Gadkari is being seen as a potential rival to Modi. Gadkari’s stature as a seasoned leader and his experience in managing key portfolios, especially infrastructure, have made him an influential figure, and some political analysts believe he has been viewed as a counterbalance to Modi’s dominance within the party.

While Gadkari’s rejection of the offer reflects his loyalty to the BJP’s organizational structure, the timing of his comments has raised eyebrows. The BJP’s performance in the recent Lok Sabha elections was weaker than expected, and during this period, many political observers speculated about a potential shift in leadership. Gadkari’s name was frequently floated as a possible alternative to Modi, with some opposition leaders even showing interest in backing him for the top post in a coalition government.

The tension between Gadkari and Modi has long been a topic of discussion in political circles. Gadkari’s prominence predates Modi’s meteoric rise in the national political scene around 2012-2013. During this period, Modi, along with his close allies Amit Shah and J.P. Nadda, consolidated his leadership within the BJP, marginalizing several senior leaders, including Gadkari. Despite his exclusion from Modi’s inner circle, Gadkari has maintained his influence, particularly in infrastructure development, and his name continues to command respect within the party and beyond.

With his recent remarks, Gadkari has once again underscored his unique position in Indian politics—remaining loyal to his ideology and the BJP, yet commanding a broader appeal that extends even to opposition circles. Whether this will lead to further shifts within the BJP’s power dynamics remains to be seen.
Education, Politics, West Bengal

Upper Primary Merit List Released Following Calcutta High Court Order: A 9-Year Wait Ends for 14,000 Candidates

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, 26 September 2024, Calcutta – After nearly nine years of delays and legal hurdles, job aspirants for upper primary teaching positions in West Bengal can finally see light at the end of the tunnel. The long-awaited merit list for over 14,000 vacancies was published on Wednesday evening on the School Service Commission (SSC) website, following a directive from the Calcutta High Court.


The recruitment process had been stalled due to a series of legal challenges since 2015. The situation became more complicated with the cancellation of recruitment efforts by the High Court in 2020, followed by an order in 2023 allowing the publication of a panel. Since then, the case passed through multiple hearings, including the Division Bench of the High Court.

In its August 2024 ruling, the Calcutta High Court instructed the SSC to release the merit list within four weeks. That order culminated in the list being published on Wednesday, finally clearing the way for the stalled recruitment process. Education Minister Bratya Basu had earlier signaled that the merit list was ready for release, providing hope to job seekers who had been waiting anxiously.

As a result of the High Court’s decision, the recruitment of 14,052 candidates must be finalized by November 21. According to the SSC, a total of 14,339 vacancies are available, and the publication of the merit list marks a crucial step toward filling these long-standing positions.

For the thousands of aspirants who have been waiting since 2015, the release of the merit list represents the fulfillment of their long-standing demands. “The wait of almost nine years is finally over,” said one hopeful candidate, expressing the relief shared by many.

However, the legal process has not yet concluded entirely. The case has now reached the Supreme Court, although the High Court’s recent ruling has paved the way for the recruitment to proceed without further delays at this stage.

With the list now available and the recruitment process back on track, the aspirants are one step closer to securing long-awaited teaching jobs, bringing an end to nearly a decade of uncertainty.
Career / Jobs, Politics, West Bengal

Mamata Banerjee Announces 12,000 New Police Jobs Amid Festive Cheer, Pending Court Case

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, 26 September 2024, Calcutta – In a significant announcement ahead of the Durga Puja festivities, Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee revealed that 12,000 new positions will soon be available in the West Bengal Police. Speaking at a high-profile meeting in Nabanna on Thursday, Banerjee stated that the recruitment notification would be officially published on Monday, bringing a wave of excitement to job seekers across the state.


This surprise announcement came right after a major health sector review meeting. Banerjee’s declaration of the police recruitment drive has been met with enthusiasm, particularly among aspiring candidates eager for government employment. “It is a welcome relief ahead of the festive season,” said one job seeker, reflecting the collective optimism sparked by the announcement.

However, the Chief Minister also acknowledged that the recruitment process is subject to an ongoing legal case. “The posts will be filled, but we must first resolve the legal entanglements. Once that’s sorted, the recruitment will proceed,” Banerjee clarified, urging patience while the matter is addressed in court. The court case, which pertains to certain procedural aspects of the hiring process, has caused some delay, but the Chief Minister assured that once legal hurdles are cleared, the recruitment will move forward swiftly.

This development comes as a double boon, with the festive spirit of Puja amplified by the promise of new job opportunities in the state. The 12,000 vacancies, which include both new and previously unfilled positions, are expected to bolster the state’s law enforcement capabilities.

Mamata Banerjee’s announcement is seen as a strategic move ahead of the upcoming elections, showcasing her government’s focus on employment and development. With law enforcement playing a critical role in maintaining order in the state, especially during high-profile events like Durga Puja, the move is likely to boost both public morale and security in the region.

As the legal process unfolds, all eyes will be on Monday’s official notification, with thousands eagerly awaiting their chance to join the West Bengal Police force.
National, Politics

Kangana Ranaut Calls for Reinstatement of Repealed Agriculture Laws, Sparks Political Debate

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, 26 September 2024, Delhi – BJP MP and actress Kangana Ranaut has stirred controversy by demanding the reinstatement of the three repealed agriculture laws, claiming they were in the best interest of farmers. Ranaut, who represents Mandi in Himachal Pradesh, urged farmers to unite and advocate for the return of the laws for their own prosperity. Her remarks have caused discomfort within the BJP, especially with the upcoming Haryana assembly elections looming.


Speaking on the issue, Kangana said, “What I am saying may spark debate, but I believe the agriculture laws should be brought back because they were designed to benefit farmers. It’s important for the farming community to raise this demand for their own development. Farmers are the backbone of the country’s progress, and only a few states opposed these laws.”

Ranaut’s comments have led to a political uproar, with the Congress seizing the opportunity to criticize the BJP. Congress leaders have accused the ruling party of trying to reintroduce the controversial laws through backdoor channels, using Kangana as a spokesperson. “Kangana’s statements are not isolated. This is a deliberate move by the BJP to test the waters ahead of future elections,” claimed a senior Congress leader, suggesting the BJP has hidden motives regarding the agriculture laws.

The three agriculture laws, which were passed in 2020, sparked massive protests, particularly in Punjab and Haryana, and were eventually repealed by the government in November 2021. The laws had sought to deregulate agricultural markets, allowing private players greater access, but were met with widespread opposition from farmers who feared losing their livelihood and being exploited by large corporations.

While the BJP has distanced itself from Ranaut’s comments, her call to bring back the repealed laws has put the party in a delicate position, especially with farmers being a key voting bloc in Haryana. Many within the BJP are wary of reigniting the controversy, which had once led to a year-long protest and strained relations with farmers across several states.

Kangana’s statements, while in line with her staunch support for the central government’s policies, have placed the BJP in a difficult spot as it tries to balance appeasing its core support base without reigniting public anger over the contentious laws. The party has yet to officially comment on her demand, but political analysts believe the timing of her statement, just before the Haryana elections, could affect the BJP’s electoral prospects.

As debates surrounding the agriculture laws resurface, Kangana’s outspoken views have once again thrust her into the center of political discourse, raising questions about the future of these contentious reforms.
Politics, West Bengal

BJP MLA Shankar Ghosh Demands Mamata Banerjee’s Resignation, Draws Parallels to Lalu Prasad’s Arrest Amid RG Kar Case Protests

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, 26 September 2024, Kolkata – In a scathing attack on the West Bengal Chief Minister, BJP MLA Shankar Ghosh from Siliguri has called for Mamata Banerjee’s resignation, citing her alleged involvement in shielding criminals in the state. Speaking at a public meeting in Hazra, Ghosh stirred controversy by comparing Banerjee to convicted political leaders like Lalu Prasad Yadav, asking, “If Lalu Prasad can be arrested, why not Mamata?”


The public meeting, organized with permission from the High Court, was part of the BJP’s broader protest against the RG Kar Medical College incident, where accusations of criminal activities have rocked the state’s political landscape. Ghosh, in his speech, emphasized that the demand for Banerjee’s resignation goes hand in hand with the need for accountability in the RG Kar case, where multiple allegations of corruption and mismanagement have surfaced.

“The chief minister is the main driving force behind the criminals in this state,” Ghosh asserted. “We are not just seeking punishment for the criminals involved in the RG Kar case, but also the resignation of Mamata Banerjee, who has repeatedly failed to bring law and order under control. Without her stepping down, the root cause of criminal protection will remain unaddressed.”

The RG Kar case, which has ignited political tensions in West Bengal, involves accusations of corruption and irregularities at RG Kar Medical College, leading to widespread protests from the BJP. The state’s BJP leaders, including Ghosh, have accused the Trinamool Congress (TMC) of shielding those involved in the alleged scandal and failing to ensure justice.

Ghosh’s reference to Lalu Prasad Yadav, the former Bihar Chief Minister who was arrested and convicted in corruption cases, marks a significant escalation in political rhetoric. His comparison suggests that, in the BJP’s view, Banerjee should face similar consequences if found culpable in facilitating or protecting criminal activities. “The law should be applied equally, and if Lalu can be arrested, there’s no reason why Mamata Banerjee should be spared from facing justice,” Ghosh stated, drawing cheers from the crowd.

The demand for Banerjee’s resignation has now become the central slogan of the BJP’s ongoing campaign in West Bengal, as the party continues to challenge the ruling TMC on issues of corruption, governance, and law enforcement. Ghosh’s remarks have added fuel to the fire, intensifying the pressure on the state government.

BJP leaders argue that Banerjee’s leadership is directly linked to the alleged criminal activities in the state, and unless she steps down, meaningful justice will remain elusive. “It is becoming clearer to the people of Bengal that the chief minister’s resignation is not just a political demand but a necessary step for justice,” Ghosh added, urging the public to rally behind the BJP’s call for change.

As the protests against the RG Kar case gather momentum, the political landscape in West Bengal is once again heating up, with the BJP positioning itself as the party demanding accountability and justice.
National, Politics

Mehbooba Mufti Declares PDP’s Central Role in Jammu and Kashmir Politics, Says BJP ‘Won’t Even Get 15 Seats’

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, 26 September 2024, New Delhi – In a bold statement during her election campaign in Jammu and Kashmir, People’s Democratic Party (PDP) chief Mehbooba Mufti asserted that it would be impossible to form a government in the state without the PDP’s involvement. With only one phase of voting remaining in the ongoing Jammu and Kashmir elections, Mufti’s declaration has ignited widespread discussion in political circles, further intensifying the already charged atmosphere.


As the state heads towards the final round of polling, all eyes are on the eventual outcome and the battle for what is often referred to as the “throne of heaven.” Mufti, confident of her party’s influence, dismissed the Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP) chances, claiming they would not even secure 15 seats in the state assembly. “The BJP will never be able to form a government in Jammu and Kashmir,” Mufti declared, adding that the PDP would support the formation of any secular government in the region.

Her comments signal the PDP’s intent to play a pivotal role in shaping the future political landscape of Jammu and Kashmir, with or without a clear majority. Mufti also underlined the need for international attention on the region’s governance, implying that broader support, beyond domestic politics, could be essential in resolving the state’s complex issues.

In a sharp attack on the BJP, Mufti criticized the party’s approach to Jammu and Kashmir, emphasizing how her late father, former Chief Minister Mufti Mohammad Sayeed, had worked tirelessly to uphold the Indian national flag during the Kashmir unrest of the 1960s. She expressed her outrage at Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s criticism of her family, labeling the remarks as unjust and politically motivated. “The Prime Minister came to Jammu and Kashmir not to address the concerns of the people here but to malign me and my family,” she said, accusing Modi of lacking a genuine agenda for the state.

Mufti highlighted the sacrifices made by her family in the name of national unity, reiterating that her father had stood by India during its most difficult times in Kashmir, contrary to the anti-national label recently thrown at them by BJP leaders. “We have kept the Indian flag aloft in this region during the most turbulent times, and yet we are being called anti-national today,” she added, pointing out the irony in the BJP’s rhetoric.

As the final phase of polling approaches, Mufti’s statements have drawn sharp reactions from her political opponents, but her supporters remain hopeful that the PDP will emerge as a key player in the formation of the next government. Whether or not the BJP can counter her claims will become clear when the election results are announced.
Health, Politics, West Bengal

Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee Holds Mega Health Review Meeting at Nabanna, Announces Major Reforms and Allocations

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, 26 September 2024, Calcutta – Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee presided over a significant health sector review meeting at Nabanna on Thursday, convening top officials from across the state’s healthcare system. In attendance were the principals of state medical colleges, superintendents of government hospitals, heads of various departments, district magistrates, and senior law enforcement officers, including superintendents of police.


During the extensive discussions, the Chief Minister focused on critical areas of West Bengal’s healthcare infrastructure and governance. Addressing journalists following the meeting, she outlined the key issues and decisions taken to enhance the state’s healthcare system.

One of the major announcements was the allocation of ₹100 crore towards infrastructure development, particularly aimed at improving basic amenities such as restrooms, washrooms, and the installation of CCTV systems to strengthen security within hospitals. These upgrades are seen as vital to improving the overall patient and staff experience in state-run medical facilities.

In a significant administrative reform, Chief Minister Banerjee announced that the chairmanship of Patient Welfare Associations (PWAs) would now be assigned to the principals of the respective medical colleges. This shift is expected to streamline decision-making and improve the efficiency of patient care management at these institutions. “The principal will directly oversee the welfare of the patients, ensuring quicker and more responsive action,” she emphasized.

Security within government hospitals also emerged as a key focus. The Chief Minister revealed that Surjit Kar Purkayastha, a veteran officer, has been appointed to oversee security measures across state medical facilities. This move comes in the wake of concerns over hospital safety and the need for a more robust security framework to protect patients, staff, and infrastructure.

Furthering the push for modernized governance, the Chief Minister called for the immediate introduction of biometric systems in state medical institutions. This step is aimed at enhancing accountability and ensuring punctuality among staff, which has been a persistent concern in the state’s healthcare sector.

Chief Minister Banerjee’s comprehensive review and subsequent announcements mark a decisive step towards addressing the longstanding challenges within the public healthcare system in West Bengal. With an emphasis on infrastructure, security, and administrative reform, her government is seeking to provide more efficient and patient-friendly services across the state.
Politics, West Bengal

Shuvendu Adhikari Comments on Haji Nurul Islam’s Death and Upcoming By-Election

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, September 26, 2024, Basirhat: Following the death of Haji Nurul Islam, state opposition leader Shuvendu Adhikari addressed the media regarding BJP candidate Rekha Patra from the Basirhat Lok Sabha constituency. He emphasized that any death is tragic and expressed condolences for the late Trinamool MP.


With the Basirhat constituency now vacant, questions are arising about the BJP’s chances of success in the upcoming by-election. When asked if the BJP would field Rekha Patra again, Shuvendu pointed out that by-elections are mandated by the Election Commission in such circumstances. He noted the significance of the Basirhat constituency and recalled how the Maniktala assembly constituency experienced delays in voting due to election petitions following the passing of state minister Sadhan Pandey.

As speculation grows about the BJP’s strategy in the Basirhat constituency, Shuvendu Adhikari’s comments highlight the complexities surrounding the political landscape following recent events.
National, Politics

IJU Hails Bombay HC Verdict Striking Down FCU

Leave a comment

KalimNews, New Delhi, 25 September 2024: The Indian Journalists Union (IJU) welcomes Bombay High Court order striking down as “unconstitutional” the amended IT Rules, 2021 rules which empower the Centre to identify “fake news” on social media platforms through a Fact Check Unit (FCU).

On Friday last, a third judge, Justice Atul S Chandurkar, gave the deciding opinion after a two-judge bench had given a split verdict on the petitions, challenging validity of the rules as being ultra vires or exceeding provisions of IT Act, 2000. He agreed with petitioners the rules were violative of Article 14 (equality before law) and 19 (1) (a) and 19 (1) (g) of Constitution (right to freedom of speech and expression, and right to practice a profession or trade).

As per IT rules amended in April 2023, content marked by FCU as “fake or misleading” will have to be taken down by online intermediaries if they wish to retain their “safe harbour” (legal immunity against 3rd-party content). 

The petitioners, stand-up comedian Kunal Kumra, Editors Guild of India, News Broadcasters and Digital Association, Association of Indian Magazines, had challenged these saying the rules made central government the sole arbiter of truth in respect of its business, obliging private parties to impose that version of truth on all users. “This provision, therefore, makes the government the sole gatekeeper of the marketplace of ideas and constitutes a clear breach of Article 19(1)(a) (freedom of speech and expression).” 

While stating that expressions “fake, false or misleading” are “vague and overbroad”, and “test of proportionality” is not satisfied, Justice Chandurkar noted it was also “not a responsibility of the state to ensure that citizens are entitled only to ‘information’ that was not fake, false or misleading as identified

by FCU”. There was “no basis or rationale” to determine whether information viz Central Government business is either fake or false when in digital form, while not taking similar exercise when the same information is in print. The impugned rule resulted in a “chilling effect” for the intermediary.

In a statement, IJU President and former member of Press Council of India Geetartha Pathak and Secretary General and International Federation of Journalists (IFJ) Vice President Sabina Inderjit said the verdict has not only safeguarded the right to freedom of speech and expression but has protected the citizens’ right to information. The Centre’s FCU would have led to veiled censorship as well as had a chilling effect on freedom of speech, essential to democracy.

Politics, West Bengal

Hooghly MP Rachna Banerjee Criticizes DVC’s Water Management Amid Flood Crisis

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, 25 September 2024, Hooghly: Hooghly MP Rachna Banerjee, while visiting the flood-affected region of Balagarh in Hooghly on Wednesday, expressed her concerns about the ongoing crisis caused by water discharge from the Damodar Valley Corporation (DVC). Addressing the media, Banerjee said, “Quintals of water are being released, leaving people homeless. Houses are submerged, and residents have been forced onto the streets.” She added that while she does not have all the facts, “what is happening is not right.”


Banerjee’s remarks sparked a sharp response from the local BJP leadership. BJP General Secretary of Hooghly, Suresh Saw, mocked her for conflating the measurement of water with “quintals,” suggesting, “The Chief Minister should place the MP in a museum for making such statements.” Saw’s jab was part of a broader critique of the Trinamool Congress’s handling of the situation.

In her defense, Banerjee said the central government has not provided adequate support for crucial flood control projects, including the Ghatal Master Plan. She praised Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee for her initiative in addressing the issue, adding that efforts are underway to explore solutions for erosion control in Balagarh.

Banerjee remained critical of the DVC but refrained from commenting further on the Chief Minister’s stance, saying, “I won’t say more about what our respected leader has already stated.”

The controversy over the “quintal” remark has continued to gain attention, with BJP leaders sarcastically referring to Banerjee as the “water queen.
Politics, West Bengal

Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury: A Leader’s Struggle for Respect and Party Unity in West Bengal

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, September 24, 2024, Kolkata: In a surprising turn of events, five-time Congress MP Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury faced a significant setback in the recent Lok Sabha elections, losing his seat in the Baharampur constituency. Many had anticipated that this loss would not diminish his standing within the party; however, he has now been removed from his position as the president of the West Bengal Congress, with Subhankar Sarkar stepping in as his successor.

Despite his efforts to sustain the party’s presence in the state, Chowdhury’s departure raises questions about his future role and influence. Speculation surrounds the decision by the Congress high command, with some suggesting that his “radical” approach toward Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee may have played a part in his removal. Sarkar’s leadership is viewed as more moderate, particularly concerning opposition to the ruling party.

This shift prompts further inquiries: Could there be a potential alliance between Congress and Trinamool Congress in West Bengal, given that both parties are currently partners in the India Alliance at the national level? How will this affect the political landscape in the state, and what position will Adhir take if such a coalition emerges?

Despite losing his state leadership role, Chowdhury remains a member of the All India Working Committee of Congress, keeping him within the party’s influential circles. However, the recent changes have left many wondering about his path forward. Will he adapt to the new political dynamics, or will he continue to advocate fiercely for the Congress’s traditional stance against the Trinamool Congress?

As West Bengal navigates a complex political environment, Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury’s future decisions will be closely watched, reflecting not only his ambitions but also the evolving strategies of the Congress party in the state. The coming days will reveal whether he can regain the respect and influence he once held or if new alliances will reshape the political scene in West Bengal.
Misc, Politics, West Bengal

Compassion in Action: Mamata Banerjee Visits Flood-Affected Areas in Birbhum

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, September 24, 2024, Calcutta: In response to the devastating floods that have impacted Birbhum district, an action planning meeting was held on Tuesday to assess the situation and coordinate relief efforts. The relentless heavy rains over the past few days have caused significant chaos in the region, prompting swift action from the state government.


Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee personally visited the flood-affected villages, bringing much-needed relief and support to those in distress. “The people of my state are being engulfed by the consequences of this man-made flood. Such tragic events are rare in Bengal, and I have no purpose in life except to serve the people,” she stated during her visit.

As the waters slowly recede in various affected areas, the Chief Minister reassured residents that the government is working tirelessly to address the crisis. “Our administration is committed to rebuilding everything from homes to roads,” she emphasized, reflecting the government’s determination to restore normalcy.

During her visit, Banerjee announced that the families of migrant workers who lost their lives in the floods, as well as those who died without receiving treatment, will be provided with compensation of ₹2 lakh from the government. “I am always by their side in their sorrows,” she added, expressing her heartfelt condolences to the grieving families.

In a message of hope, the Chief Minister prayed to Maa Jagajjanani for a swift return to normalcy for all affected. “May Bengal never have to see such a sad day again. May the people of my state be freed from all calamities and sufferings,” she concluded.

The state’s proactive response and compassionate leadership during this crisis highlight the commitment to supporting those in need and rebuilding the community. As relief efforts continue, the people of Birbhum can take solace in knowing that help is on the way.
Politics, West Bengal

Celebrations in Birbhum: Anubrata Congratulates Mamata Banerjee on Durga Puja

Leave a comment

Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, September 24, 2024, Calcutta: After nearly two years of anticipation, Anubrata Mondal, the prominent Trinamool Congress (TMC) leader, has returned home, celebrating his newfound freedom following bail in the cow smuggling case. His homecoming coincides perfectly with the Durga Puja festivities, making it a moment of immense joy for his family and supporters.


Anubrata, accompanied by his daughter Sukanya, landed at Kolkata airport early on Tuesday morning. The pair was greeted with cheers and bouquets, marking a triumphant return to the city. Shortly after their arrival, they set off for Birbhum, where the atmosphere was electric with excitement and celebration.
As their car approached Birbhum, the streets were filled with chants from enthusiastic supporters who showered them with flowers. Anubrata stepped out of the vehicle to an overwhelming show of affection from his followers. Together with Sukanya, he entered their Nichupatti home, where the warm welcome continued.

Facing the media shortly after his arrival, Anubrata expressed heartfelt congratulations for the ongoing Durga Puja celebrations. He took a moment to share his deep admiration for TMC leader Mamata Banerjee, stating, “Mamata Banerjee is coming… I love Mamata Banerjee. The whole of Bengal, the people of the whole country love her.” He added, “My feet are not good. If my body is fine, I will meet Didi,” highlighting his eagerness to reconnect with the party leader.

Anubrata Mondal’s return is not only a personal victory but also a significant moment for his supporters, who have stood by him through the trials of the past years. As the Durga Puja festivities unfold, this reunion is sure to add to the joy and spirit of the season, marking a new chapter for Anubrata and the community that has warmly welcomed him back home.
Crime, Politics, West Bengal

A Warrior’s Fight: Ahmed Ibrahim Delivers on His Promise to Anubrata Mondal

Leave a comment
 Ahmed Ibrahim Fulfills Promise: Anubrata Mondal Granted Bail Before Durga Puja!
The reunion between father and daughter
Baby Chakraborty, KalimNews, September 24, 2024, Calcutta: In a moment of triumph and emotion, lawyer Ahmed Ibrahim successfully secured bail for his client, Anubrata Mondal, just in time for the Durga Puja celebrations. Known for his unwavering dedication, Ibrahim has been a steadfast advocate for Mondal, who has faced a long and arduous legal battle.

Mondal, affectionately known as Kesto, emerged from jail wearing a yellow-grey T-shirt, visibly emotional after a year and a half of legal struggles. His daughter, Sukanya Mondal, who had previously been released on bail, was there to greet him as he stepped out. For the first time in many months, Kesto walked out on his own, having previously arrived at court in a wheelchair.

The reunion between father and daughter was poignant, with emotional hugs exchanged as they embraced their newfound freedom. Following his release, Kesto was seen leaving for a hotel near the airport, where he shared a heartfelt moment with Ibrahim, both of them in tears.

Ahmed Ibrahim expressed his commitment to his client during the process, stating that he promised Kesto he would bring him home before the 2024 Durga Puja festivities. “I kept my promise,” he told the media, highlighting his determination throughout the lengthy court proceedings.

Mondal’s journey to freedom follows a tumultuous period, having been arrested by the CBI in August 2022 in connection with a cow smuggling case, and later detained again by the Enforcement Directorate. Despite the challenges, Kesto remained resilient, and today he is looking forward to reuniting with family and friends to celebrate the upcoming festivities.

This victory is not just a personal triumph for Kesto and his family but also a reminder of the perseverance and dedication of those who fight for justice. As Durga Puja approaches, the significance of this moment is felt deeply within the community, marking a new chapter for Anubrata Mondal.